Nurse Unfairly Dismissed Because Of Her Weight

A South Australian nurse has been awarded three years’ back pay after being unfairly dismissed because of her weight.

The nurse was awarded three years’ backpay and has been reinstated to her role after she was unfairly dismissed from her job due to her obesity and associated issues performing her role. The nurse had been working for her employer for 25 years and was dismissed in 2018 after a 14-month suspension for allegedly being unable to perform her duties due to her weight, a knee condition and falling asleep at work. The South Australian Employment Tribunal found that the dismissal was harsh, unjust and the employer had acted in breach of their anti-discrimination policies.

Before being dismissed the employee was on a performance improvement plan (PIP) that forbade her from sitting or leaning while performing her daily duties. She had been allowed to do this previously and other nurses were allowed to briefly sit between duties.

The nurse had also previously had two warnings and been reported to the Australia Health Practitioner Regulation Agency for allegedly falling asleep at work. In response, the employee had addressed the issue by attending a sleep study, undergoing CPAP therapy, and seeing a psychiatrist and psychologist.

In June 2018, the employee was told the interim CEO intended to dismiss her. This was because she was unfit to perform her role due to raised BMI, reduced cardiovascular fitness and knee arthritis, as recommended by an independent occupational physician.

The Tribunal later heard that the medical professional had only suggested giving her a more sedentary role. The employee requested alternative duties until she underwent bariatric surgery to address her weight or if that were not possible that she accesses her accrued leave until she could return to her role.

Both of these requests were denied, and the employee was terminated in late 2018. The nurse lodged an unfair dismissal claim and was referred to the South Australia Tribunal in 2020.

The Magistrate found that the PIP banning her from sitting or leaning ‘appeared to be designed to make the applicant’s duties more difficult’. It was also noted that the employer did not seriously consider appropriate sedentary roles for redeploying the employee.

The Magistrate found that the employee’s future capacity was uncertain, but it was possible with appropriate redeployment or leave that she could return to her role.  It was also found that the employee was not reasonably supported by the employer and her health issues were work-related with workers compensation claims for a knee condition and psychological injury.

The employer also ignored its HR policy to provide reasonable allowances for injured employees including taking 12 months’ leave with or without pay to address health issues. Therefore the Magistrate instructed the employee was to be reinstated with 3 years’ back pay.

Key takeaways:

  • Employers must follow due process if terminating employees and consider reasonable options for redeployment or alternative work before doing so.
  • Employers should abide by their HR policies. Ignoring internal HR policies only harms the employer if issues are taken to tribunal.
  • In the event of medical issues, employers need to be careful using the advice of medical experts and be clear with employees about the outcomes of medical assessments.
  • Employers must allow employees the opportunity to respond to claims or evidence and their responses should be seriously considered by employers.

ProcessWorx Advisors have experience terminating employees and dealing with unfair dismissal claims. If you have queries about anything above and want advice personalised to your business, contact us on (08) 9316 9896, or email

Follow ProcessWorx on LinkedInFacebookInstagramYouTube, and Twitter to keep up with the latest HR and Safety news.

Written by Danielle McNamee



More Posts

Christmas Shutdown, Annual Leave

Preparing for Christmas Shutdown

Coming into December many organisations observe a shutdown over the Christmas New Year period. However, determining employees pay during this time can be complicated. Payment

Office Christmas Party, go to guide

Go To Office Christmas Party Guide

The in the upcoming weeks Australian workplaces will celebrate the year and indulge in festivities with colleagues. The office Christmas party can be the event

Send Us A Message

Contact Us

Start your HR or Safety assessment for your business

Treat yourself

Let Us Take Care Of You

Copyright © ProcessWorx 2021